You have to plan ahead more when you're driving a manual, but I think that helps keep you focused on the road. And I think it depends how good you are at downshifting to pass someone effectively...in my mom's Passat 1.8T, it downshifts very quickly (if you are driving in Tiptronic mode), but doesn't have a lot of power below about 3,000 rpm, so on a backroad you'd have to downshift twice (into third gear) to really have much passing power. Compare that to my A6, where I can go directly from fifth gear to third gear, and the passing times are about even. And true, 0-60 isn't really a good comparison now since automatics have launch control and quicker shifts, plus for manual cars it's hard on the clutch to do repeated 0-60 runs. 5-60 evens that out somewhat, though manual will still be a tenth or two slower due to slower shifts but can hang with an automatic for longer.
I really haven't driven a car with a truly great transmission (manual or auto) in a while. My manual A6 is easy to drive, but the gearing is somewhat weird. My dad's auto Allroad 2.7T, while it has plenty of low-end torque, is difficult to drive smoothly except when I'm accelerating hard. And my mom's Passat 1.8T doesn't have enough power below 3,000 rpm to really work well with an automatic, as it is always trying to upshift before then. I did get to drive a six speed manual first-gen Audi TT though, and that was a hoot...good handling, great gearing, and nice, short throws.
You would make a post right then, Matt! :P
Last modified by
Mazdafreak, 02 March 2016, 14:46