Well, whether the gear changes are commanded via thumb shifters on the front of the steering wheel or paddles behind the wheel, the computer is still doing the shifting, and it's not as involving as using a clutch pedal and changing gears yourself.
One of the things that irks me about automated transmissions is that you end up straddling a very fine line between total gearbox automation and absolute performance by supporting them. I don't know if you read Car and Driver magazine, but they have an annual event at VIR called Lighting Lap. (The event consists of their drivers lapping the newest performance cars to see where they stack up against the competition). Recently they noted that, when trying to set a hot lap in an automatic car, they really have to just put the car in whatever track mode it offers and leave the transmission in D, as modern transmissions have gotten so smart that you hinder the car's ability by trying to shift it manually, even via the paddles.
Also, modern manual transmissions can be shifted very quickly. Know what the fastest car Car and Driver has ever lapped around VIR? A C7 Corvette Z06 with a manual trans. How about the only car that Randy Pobst (of Motor Trend) has driven faster around Mazda Raceway Laguna Seca than a new Viper ACR? A Porsche 918 Spyder, which, despite being so much more advanced, only beat the ACR around Laguna Seca by 0.6 seconds. The ACR was quicker around the track than a McLaren P1, and THREE SECONDS faster than a new Corvette Z06 and 911 GT3 RS. So it's not like the manual trans is incapable in today's world! : )
Last modified by
Mazdafreak, 03 March 2016, 15:15